Skip to main content

October Reading Life-Hillbilly Elegy Book Review


Image result for hillbilly elegy

While my reading life has slowed down some in the past month with the business of home and school, I am still really enjoying the process of selecting books and listening/reading with a purpose. I am learning so much about myself and about different cultures, and ideologies with some of the books I have read this year. That journey continues with my most recent selection, Hillbilly Elegy.

Hillbilly Elegy was written by J.D. Vance whose family originally hailed from rural Kentucky coal country before moving to Middletown, Ohio. He mixes the stories of his youth with an argument that affixes the blame of the poor “hillbillies” on themselves. He claimed that it was largely “learned helplessness” that has led to the plight of many poor working whites, who have taken advantage of the welfare system and feel that no matter what they do, they cannot improve their condition in life (Vance). When I first started reading the book, I was taken aback by the premise that we should be taking a closer look at the white working class, considering the current climate of race relations in this country. Mr. Vance seemingly has every privilege we have in American society: white, Christian, white-collar worker. However, when he describes his background, it is clear that he had to struggle in parts of his life and attended Yale law school despite the odds against him.

I was struck by his grit and unwillingness to make excuses for himself. Although, I do think he could show a little more empathy toward people born into a cycle of poverty and abuse and the role that good mentor plays in helping people break that cycle.

In 2016 The New York Times ran a book review Hillbilly Elegy, in which they took some fault with Vance’s idea that the victim is only to blame and not the structures put in place by the government. However, they did applaud him for tackling a “taboo subject” and starting the conversation.

Overall, I think this is a very interesting take on the white working class and it gives you a glimpse into our recent election results. More can be said about other aspects of the working class when it comes to race and gender, but this is certainly an eye-opening glimpse into a part one sector of American society.

Comments

  1. west virginia is the epitome of what this blog is talking about, dozens of rundown and or old mining towns stuck in time, I encourage you to take a drive through a town in the central area of the state the next time you're around

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm glad you're still enjoying reading even though you've slowed down. That has happened to me as well , but I'm still enjoying the time I have when I do have free time. The book you're reading seems very interesting. This book really seems to show life lessons.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

It Takes a Community

I gave my class the following prompt this week: Is it better to say the right thing or do the right thing? Or, in other words, do actions speak louder than words? Many times during our class discussions students have brought up that it is so hard to be kind and do the right thing sometimes. However, they do not give themselves enough credit. The field trip last Friday illustrated this beautifully. Last Friday, all of the seniors took a trip to Lorain County Community College for some climbing, high ropes, and team building. There were nerves, fear of heights (including yours truly), and excitement to get out of the classroom. Some students were literally shaking at the thought of climbing to high heights in front of their peers. Some resisted participation at first. Even I was not eager to give it a go. However, something magical began to happen as the students were taking on the various challenges. They began to cheer for, encourage, and motivate each other to higher heights. You coul...

Using the Tools of Success, Why Not?

There is a common saying that says, “work smarter, not harder.” I often find myself repeating this mantra to myself when I am spending too many hours on school work, whether planning or grading. Granted, I want others to think of me as a hard worker, who puts in many hours devoted to my teaching craft. However, it is so easy to go overboard because we associate long hours with hard work. What if we could do a simpler task or create a more efficient plan that would accomplish the same goal? I frequently find that the more simple lessons that I plan wind up being the most interactive, engaging, and thought-provoking, and it leaves me wondering why I spent so much mental energy and time planning a more complex lesson. This same idea applies to assistive technology in the classroom. When it comes to reading, writing, grading, and editing there are many tools at our disposal. From Read and Write Gold to Speech to Text, we have so many valuable tools that would make our lives easier. I ...

Using Summer and Family to Recharge and Reflect

One of the really great benefits of being a teacher is having the ability to have the summer off to grow professionally, spend time with family, and to relax and recharge for the following school year.  While I absolutely love my job as an educator at Lawrence school, it is necessary to have that time to reflect, play, and grow personally and professionally.  This past summer was filled with opportunities to do just that.   Let’s start at the beginning.  Our first order of business was to take a trip across the country to Colorado to visit friends and then on to Phoenix, Arizona to visit family.  If you have ever traveled with very young children on an airplane, you can empathize with the challenges of packing, escorting, and most importantly feeding everyone along the way.  A hungry 3-year-old is a hangry 3-year-old.  I think some adults can relate as well.  Once we got past the logistics of traveling, we were off on a great advent...